A header image showcasing a circular gradient transitioning from light to dark shades with a sleek, modern design.A footer image showcasing a circular gradient effect blending light and dark tones seamlessly.

Refinancing, personal loans or upfront rent: What Should Investors Compare?

Profile photo of Godfrey Dinh
Published · Updated
Godfrey Dinh
image alt text description

Most people only look at the interest rate when comparing financing options. But what if we told you the lowest interest rate isn't always the most affordable. But what if we told you the lowest interest rate isn't always the most affordable o...

Australian property investors looking for extra capital usually have more than one option. You might take out a personal loan. You could increase or refinance your mortgage. Or, if you own an eligible investment property, you may be able to access capital without changing the mortgage through a property-linked cash out such as Futurerent.

These options are structurally different, so comparing the interest rate alone does not tell you much. The useful comparison is broader:

How much capital can you access, what does it cost in total, what happens to your ongoing cash flow, does your mortgage change, what assessment is required, and how might the decision affect your future plans?

This guide compares personal loans, mortgage top-ups and refinancing, and Futurerent Cash Out so Australian property investors can understand the trade-offs before deciding what to investigate further.

Key Takeaways

  • A personal loan is a separate credit product with its own repayments, interest and fees. It usually leaves the existing mortgage unchanged.
  • A mortgage top-up or cash-out refinance accesses property equity by increasing or restructuring mortgage debt.
  • Futurerent works differently. Eligible investors receive a cash out against an investment property without increasing or refinancing their existing mortgage.
  • Applying for Futurerent does not affect your credit score, but credit score and future borrowing capacity are different questions.
  • The fastest or lowest-rate option is not necessarily the lowest-cost option overall. Compare the full cost, term and cash-flow impact.
  • Futurerent can provide eligible investors with up to $100,000 per property, up to $500,000 across multiple properties, with funds available in 2 business days once approved.
  • No single option is best for every investor. The right comparison depends on how much you need, why you need it and what you plan to do next.

What Are the Three Options?

At a high level, the three paths solve the same problem in different ways. You want capital today. The question is what changes in exchange for getting it.

Personal Loan

A personal loan is a separate credit facility from a bank or other lender. You borrow an agreed amount and repay it, with interest and any applicable fees, over a set term. Personal loans can be secured or unsecured. With an unsecured personal loan, you do not generally provide an asset such as your investment property as security.

Your existing mortgage usually remains unchanged, but the personal loan becomes another financial commitment. ASIC's Moneysmart notes that personal-loan terms are commonly between one and seven years. The rate offered can depend on factors including your credit score, income, expenses and savings.

When comparing personal loans, look at the comparison rate, fees, term and total amount you will repay rather than focusing only on the advertised interest rate. You can read more in the Moneysmart guide to personal loans.

Mortgage Top-Up or Cash-Out Refinance

A mortgage top-up increases the amount available through your existing home or investment loan. A cash-out refinance generally involves increasing or replacing an existing mortgage and receiving some of the additional borrowing as cash. In either case, you are accessing property equity by taking on more mortgage debt.

The lender will generally assess your broader financial position, which may include: income, living expenses, existing debts, rental income, serviceability, credit history and the property's value.

That can make sense where you qualify for additional mortgage borrowing and are comfortable increasing the amount secured against the property. Refinancing may also suit investors who already want to change lender, negotiate their mortgage structure or review the overall loan. However, refinancing can involve costs beyond the headline interest rate.

ASIC's Moneysmart recommends checking potential discharge, application, switching and break fees, lender's mortgage insurance where relevant, and the length of the new loan. Extending borrowing over a longer term can reduce the regular payment while increasing the total interest paid.

Read more in our guide to cash-out refinancing for property investors.

Futurerent Cash Out

Futurerent is structurally different from both options. It is not a personal loan or mortgage. Futurerent enters into a concurrent lease with the investment property owner and provides a rental prepayment upfront. In exchange, Futurerent becomes entitled to receive an agreed amount of future rent from the property.

Eligible investors can cash out up to $100,000 per investment property, up to $500,000 across multiple properties. The existing mortgage stays in place. Futurerent does not require personal income and expense statements. Approval is primarily based on the investment property, its rental income, equity and other eligibility criteria.

Applying involves a soft credit check with the investor's consent, which does not leave a hard credit enquiry or affect the investor's credit score. Once approved and the required documents are completed, funds can be transferred in 2 business days. The tenant continues paying rent to the property manager as normal. The property manager directs an agreed portion of the rent collected to Futurerent and sends the remaining rental income to the investor.

In simple terms:

You receive more capital upfront, while the property returns the cash out from an agreed portion of future rent.

Personal Loan vs Mortgage Top-Up vs Futurerent

Factor Personal loan Mortgage top-up / refinance Futurerent Cash Out
Structure Separate credit product Additional or restructured mortgage debt Rental prepayment through concurrent lease
Existing mortgage Usually unchanged Increased or restructured Unchanged
Credit application Credit assessment generally required Credit assessment generally required Soft credit check, no credit-score impact
Personal income and expenses Assessed by lender Assessed by lender No personal income or expense statements
Amount available Depends on lender and applicant Depends on equity and lender assessment Up to $100K/property, $500K/client
Time to funding Depends on lender and application Depends on lender, valuation and application 2 business days once approved
Ongoing cash-flow impact Loan repayments from available cash flow Higher or new mortgage payments Agreed portion of rent goes to Futurerent
Main trade-off Adds a separate debt and repayment commitment Adds or restructures debt secured against the property You receive less rental income during the arrangement

The purpose of this table is not to declare a winner. The products are fundamentally different.

Use it to identify which trade-offs matter most to you, then compare the actual costs and terms available for your circumstances.

How Does Each Option Affect Your Credit Score?

A credit score and borrowing capacity are related concepts, but they are not the same thing.

Personal Loan

Applying for a personal loan generally involves a credit application. Credit enquiries are recorded on your credit report, and making many credit applications in a short period can affect your credit score. If the loan is approved, you also have an additional credit commitment that a future lender may consider.

Mortgage Top-Up or Refinance

Applying for additional mortgage credit or refinancing generally also involves a lender assessing your credit history. The important financial change is that you are increasing or replacing mortgage debt. That increased debt and its associated payments can then form part of future lending assessments.

Futurerent

Applying for Futurerent does not affect your credit score. Futurerent uses a soft credit check through Equifax with your consent. This does not leave a hard credit enquiry on your record.

Futurerent also does not increase the balance of your existing mortgage. However, that does not mean Futurerent can never affect future borrowing capacity. That distinction matters.

Does Futurerent Affect Future Borrowing Capacity?

Borrowing capacity refers to how much a lender is prepared to lend you after assessing your income, debts, expenses and other financial commitments. Futurerent does not appear as additional mortgage debt and does not affect your credit score.

But while the Futurerent arrangement is active, part of the property's rental income goes to Futurerent. If you apply for another mortgage, a lender may consider that when deciding how much rental income is available to service your debts. Different banks and credit officers can treat this differently.

If another financed property purchase is part of your plan, your mortgage broker is best placed to advise on how a particular lender may assess your Futurerent arrangement. This is why access to a deposit and borrowing capacity for the next mortgage should be treated as two separate questions.

Having enough capital for a deposit does not automatically mean a lender will approve the remaining purchase price.

How Does the Assessment Process Differ?

Personal Loan Assessment

Personal-loan providers generally assess whether you can afford the loan. That can include your income, expenses, existing debts, employment and credit history.

The exact documentation and assessment criteria vary by lender. Avoid assuming that every lender requires the same documents or uses the same serviceability formula.

Mortgage Top-Up or Refinance Assessment

Mortgage lenders generally look at both the property and the borrower. That may include: income, expenses, existing debts, rental income, credit history, property value and overall serviceability.

Having substantial equity does not guarantee that a lender will approve you to access it. The lender still needs to determine whether you meet its borrowing criteria.

Futurerent Assessment

Futurerent does not require personal income and expense statements. Approval is primarily property-based.

The property generally needs to meet Futurerent's eligibility criteria, including being an eligible residential investment property, being professionally managed or having a property manager appointed, generating sufficient rent and retaining sufficient equity after the cash out.

Futurerent also completes a soft credit check with the investor's consent.

How Should You Compare the Total Cost?

This is where the old version of this article was misleading. A mortgage, personal loan and Futurerent should not be compared by simply putting three percentage rates next to each other.

They work differently and can run for very different periods. Instead, compare the total dollar outcome.

Personal Loan

For a personal loan, consider the interest rate, comparison rate, loan term, establishment fees, ongoing fees and any early repayment costs. A shorter loan term may mean higher regular repayments while reducing the period over which interest is charged.

ASIC's Moneysmart personal-loan calculator can help compare the total cost of different loan structures.

Mortgage Top-Up or Refinance

Mortgage rates may be lower than unsecured credit rates, but the term matters. Adding an expense to a long mortgage term can produce relatively small monthly payments while still creating substantial total interest over time.

If refinancing, also consider costs such as discharge fees, application fees, switching costs, break costs and lender's mortgage insurance where applicable. ASIC's Moneysmart specifically recommends comparing the total amount to be paid back, not just the interest rate.

Futurerent

Futurerent's cost is fixed based on the amount and term selected. It is not a loan, so there is no loan interest compounding over a mortgage term. Instead, Futurerent receives an agreed fixed amount of rent in exchange for providing the cash out upfront.

Because pricing can change, the best place to see the current figures is the Futurerent calculator. The calculator lets you see the amount you may be able to cash out, the total cost, how much rent goes to Futurerent and how much rental income remains for you.

When comparing it with a personal loan or mortgage option, compare the total dollar cost and cash-flow effect, not just one percentage.

How Quickly Can You Access Capital?

Timeframes for personal loans and mortgage finance depend on the lender, applicant and complexity of the transaction. A personal loan may require less property-related work than a mortgage refinance, while a mortgage application can involve additional steps such as property valuation and settlement.

Rather than relying on a universal “two weeks” or “six weeks” estimate, ask the lender what their current expected timeframe is for your application. Futurerent has a published timeframe.

The online application takes around two minutes, eligibility is generally advised within one business day, and once formally approved and the required documents are completed, funds are typically transferred within 2 business days. That can matter when the reason for accessing capital has a deadline.

Scenario 1: Funding the Next Investment Property

Suppose you own an investment property with equity and want $80,000 towards another purchase. A mortgage top-up or refinance may be worth considering if you have sufficient equity and serviceability and are comfortable increasing the mortgage.

A personal loan is another form of credit, but the additional debt and repayments would form part of a future mortgage lender's assessment. Futurerent could allow an eligible investor to access up to $100,000 from the existing investment property without increasing that mortgage.

But there is an important distinction:

Futurerent may help provide capital for the deposit, but the investor still needs to qualify for the mortgage on the new property.

A future lender may also take the reduced rental income during the Futurerent arrangement into account when assessing serviceability. If another property purchase is the goal, involve your mortgage broker before choosing how to fund the deposit. For more on this strategy, see our guide to accessing investment property equity.

Scenario 2: Funding Repairs or a Renovation

Suppose your investment property needs $25,000 of work. You might have several options. If you have sufficient savings, using cash may be simplest. A personal loan could fund the project without changing your mortgage, but creates another credit commitment.

A mortgage top-up may provide access to property equity, subject to the lender's assessment. Futurerent could provide eligible investors with a cash out while keeping the existing mortgage unchanged. The best comparison depends on what the work is expected to achieve, the total funding cost and what happens to your cash flow afterwards.

If the renovation is expected to increase rent, reduce vacancy or improve the property, compare those benefits with the cost of accessing the capital. Read more in our guide to funding investment property repairs and renovations.

Scenario 3: Consolidating Higher-Cost Debt

An investor might also have credit card debt, a personal loan or other higher-cost commitments alongside their investment property. Refinancing can potentially consolidate those commitments into mortgage debt.

That may reduce the regular payment, but a lower monthly payment does not necessarily mean a lower total cost. ASIC's Moneysmart warns that consolidating debt over a longer term can result in paying more overall even if the new interest rate is lower.

Another personal loan may also be used for debt consolidation, depending on the lender and the investor's circumstances. Futurerent can provide capital that the investor may choose to use to reduce or clear other obligations without increasing their existing mortgage.

However, the investor should compare the total cost of the existing debts with the cost and rental cash-flow impact of Futurerent. The objective should be to improve the overall financial position, not simply move an obligation from one structure to another.

Which Option Should You Investigate?

A personal loan may be worth comparing when you want a separate credit facility, do not want to change the mortgage and are comfortable with its repayments and total cost. A mortgage top-up or refinance may be worth comparing when you have sufficient equity and serviceability, are comfortable increasing secured debt, or already want to review the structure of your mortgage.

Futurerent may be worth comparing when you own an eligible investment property, want to keep the existing mortgage in place, value property-based approval, do not want to provide personal income and expense statements, or need capital relatively quickly.

None of those descriptions mean the option is automatically suitable. Before deciding, compare how much capital you need, timing, total cost, ongoing cash flow, the assessment process and what you plan to do next.

Personal Loan vs Investment Property Equity Release: The Bottom Line

There is no universal winner between a personal loan, mortgage equity release and Futurerent. They solve the same need for upfront capital using very different structures. A personal loan adds a separate debt.

A mortgage top-up or refinance increases or restructures mortgage debt. Futurerent keeps the existing mortgage unchanged and provides capital in exchange for an agreed amount of future rental income.

The useful question is not: “Which one has the lowest advertised rate?”

It is: “What does each option cost me in total, what changes after I use it, and which structure makes sense for what I'm trying to achieve?”

If you want to include Futurerent in that comparison, use the Futurerent calculator to see your indicative cash-out amount, current cost and estimated impact on rental cash flow. For personal loans and mortgage options, compare current products directly with the relevant lender or mortgage broker.

FAQs About Personal Loans and Investment Property Equity Release

Does Futurerent affect my credit score?

No. Futurerent conducts a soft credit check through Equifax with your consent. It does not leave a hard credit enquiry on your record or affect your credit score.

Does Futurerent affect my borrowing capacity?

It can affect how a future lender assesses your serviceability even though it does not affect your credit score or increase your existing mortgage. While the arrangement is active, an agreed portion of rental income goes to Futurerent.

A future lender may therefore treat that amount as an expense or reduce the rental income it considers available for debt service. Different lenders may assess this differently, so speak with your mortgage broker if you expect to apply for another mortgage.

Can I use a personal loan for an investment property deposit?

Potentially, depending on the personal-loan provider and permitted use of the funds. However, when you apply for the mortgage on the investment property, the personal loan is an existing financial commitment and may affect the lender's serviceability assessment. Having a deposit and qualifying for the mortgage are separate requirements.

Is refinancing cheaper than Futurerent?

Not necessarily, and the two products are structurally different. A mortgage may have a lower interest rate, but total cost depends on the amount borrowed, loan term, fees and how quickly the additional debt is repaid.

Futurerent has a fixed cost and is generally structured over a much shorter period. Compare the total dollar cost and cash-flow impact for your circumstances rather than comparing headline percentages alone.

How long does refinancing take?

There is no single timeframe that applies to every lender or investor. Timing depends on factors including the lender, documentation, valuation requirements, complexity of the application and settlement process. Ask the lender or mortgage broker for a current estimate based on your circumstances.

What can I use a Futurerent cash out for?

There is no single required purpose. Investors use Futurerent for property deposits, buyer's agent fees, renovations, repairs, strata and other property expenses, cash-flow buffers, family needs, business costs, debt consolidation and investment diversification.

What happens if the tenant stops paying rent?

If no rent is being collected because the tenant has moved out or is in arrears, you do not need to make a separate payment to Futurerent from your own funds during that period. It simply takes Futurerent longer to receive the fixed amount of rent it is due.

The agreed Futurerent cost does not increase because of the vacancy or arrears.

Cash out calculator

Zero obligations

No credit impact

Property based approval

Fast, simple, no credit impact.

Weekly rent must be at least $250
Please complete all fields before calculating.

You can get up to

$0

error

/ upfront advance

$0

$0

Breakdown

Cashflow
Pricing
Here's how this is returned

Rental income

$0 /mo

$0 /mo

Advanced returned

(inc. $0 cost )

$0 /mo

Remaining for you

Breakdown of the fixed costs
Total estimated cash out
$ upfront
Estimates subject to approval
Total setup cost (out of pocket)
$ upfront
Cost per year excl. setup costs
$ p.a
Expected term
months

The cost of using Futurerent is twofold: (1) an initial setup cost of $2,900 (incl. GST) for advances up to $30,000, $3,900 (incl. GST) for advances between $30,001 and $60,000, and $4,500 (incl. GST) for advances between $60,001 and $100,000; and 
(2) a fixed amount of the rental income that Futurerent earns from the property.

Setup cost

$ 0

The basic criteria

To access your advance, your investment property must:

Be professionally managed by a property manager (we can help).

Not be held in a self-managed super fund (SMSF).

Not be used for short-term rentals (Airbnb or holiday letting).

Not be an NDIS-funded property.

Disclaimer

Please note that the information on this page is general information only and should not be taken as constituting professional or financial advice. Futurerent is not a financial adviser. You should consider seeking independent legal, financial, taxation or other advice to check how the information on this page relates to your unique circumstances. Futurerent is not liable for any loss caused, whether due to negligence or otherwise arising from the use of, or reliance on, the information provided directly or indirectly, by use of this website.