Which is the better deal: refinancing, personal loans or upfront rent?

Profile photo of Godfrey Dinh
April 5, 2023
Godfrey Dinh
image alt text description

Most people only look at the interest rate when comparing financing options. But what if we told you the lowest interest rate isn't always the most affordable. But what if we told you the lowest interest rate isn't always the most affordable o...

Any property investor who has refinanced their home loan will agree that it’s a painful process. So painful that it only makes sense to do it if the numbers really stack in your favour.

If you refinance your home loan to get a better deal, you’ll most likely be comparing interest rates to save money in the long term.

But if you’re a property investor refinancing to increase (or top up) your home loan, this isn’t necessarily going to be your best option, especially if you don’t need a huge amount of money.

What about personal loans? People generally use personal loans when they need fast access to money for a specific use, as lenders which provide these are typically more relaxed with their assessment criteria.

However, this will likely come at the expense of high interest rates, with the average unsecured personal loan rate at 14%, according to the RBA. Personal loans also come with a bunch of substantial fees, which can easily add thousands to your debt.

At Futurerent, we enable you to unlock up to $100,000 of your rental income, so you don’t have to get a new loan and deal with the banks.

Let’s run the numbers

When comparing refinancing and its alternatives, looking at interest rates alone can be misleading. This is because the repayment term is just as important. Banks love talking about the interest rates of refinancing but shy away from how long it takes to pay the entire loan off.

Confused? We’ll show you with real numbers.

Let’s say you need access to $25,000. You can choose to pay an interest rate of:

1) 3.42% per annum over 30 years – for an investor home loan top-up

2) 14% per annum over 5 years – for an unsecured personal loan

3) 9.9% per annum over 1.5 years – to access upfront rent with Futurerent over the shortest term.

Show me the money

Naturally, your eyes are drawn to the interest rate with the lower number. It can be tempting to bump that $25,000 onto your 30-year mortgage and pay it off along with the mortgage you’ve already got.

Let’s look at a second set of numbers, this time in dollar figures. Would you rather pay:

1) $15,370

2) $9,902

3) $3,713?

It’s not hard to guess which one most people would choose.

Option 1 – Pay $15,370

This is the amount of interest you’d need to pay if you topped up your mortgage by $25,000 and allowing the interest to accumulate over 30 years, based on the rates in the first set of numbers. Note that we haven’t included other refinancing costs, such as break costs, etc.

Option 2 – Pay $9,902

This is what you’d need to stump up in interest if you took out a 5-year personal loan of $25,000. While much cheaper than refinancing, this option will still set you back nearly ten grand. Not to mention multiple charges from the lender, including establishment fees and monthly account-keeping fees.

Option 3 – Pay $3,713

The final option is your cost over 1.5 years if you access $25,000 of your rental income upfront using Futurerent.

Avoid a lifetime of interest

On the surface, topping up your mortgage sounds like a set-and-forget approach, but that’s exactly what the banks want you to think. In that example, you’d be more than $13,000 worse off if you refinanced! You can also enjoy faster funding times and better flexibility than personal loans at about a fraction of the price.

So whether you’re looking to use the funds to invest in your business, buy another property or do a renovation, it’s important to crunch the numbers before making any financial decisions.


Please note that the information on this page is general information only and should not be taken as constituting professional or financial advice. Futurerent is not a financial adviser. You should consider seeking independent legal, financial, taxation or other advice to check how the information on this page relates to your unique circumstances. Futurerent is not liable for any loss caused, whether due to negligence or otherwise arising from the use of, or reliance on, the information provided directly or indirectly, by use of this website.